U.S. District Judge Melissa R. DuBose ruled against Providence College basketball players Joseph Pinion and Derek Simpson on Friday, Nov. 20, denying their motion for a preliminary injunction. The decision in the Rhode Island branch of the U.S. District Court effectively blocks the two athletes from suiting up for the Friars during the upcoming 2026-2027 season. This ruling marks a significant legal setback for the players, who had sought immediate relief to compete on the court.
Federal court rules against Pinion and Simpson, keeping them off the 2026-27 roster
In her written opinion, Judge DuBose stated that the plaintiffs “have not carried their burden” and are ineligible under the “Adopted Final legislation.” The court found that Pinion and Simpson are unlikely to succeed in demonstrating that the NCAA breached a contract by denying them eligibility. This follows an earlier denial of a temporary restraining order that would have allowed the duo to appear on the roster and play in the 2026-27 campaign, solidifying the legal stance that current NCAA regulations bar their participation.
The legal battle, which includes lawsuits filed on federal antitrust grounds, continues despite this procedural loss. A second hearing was held on Nov. 10 regarding the injunction, with local counsel Marc joining Jesse Panuccio in representing the players. For Providence, the ruling ensures roster stability for the immediate future, while the players retain the option to pursue further appeals or argue their antitrust claims in subsequent court proceedings.
Source: Yahoo Sports



